Monday, June 25, 2018

Forms of History in Woody Allen (reprint)

Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
‘History will dissolve me’, Woody Allen declares in Bananas (1971), reprising Fidel Castro’s revolution. It still well may, but not before Woody gets in his own licks against the past time that refuses to stand still, to stay buried or to stop
fattening itself by gobbling down the future. On the contrary, he has managed to harness history. In the 43 very personal films he directed in 43 years his art draws both on his life and his earlier films.
In some ways Bananas is typical of the current history implicit in all Allen’s films. As he explores always current obsessions, hypocrisies and neuroses an Allen film provides a time capsule of the culture of its day. Bananas conveys the sexual insecurities, the student activism, the (pre-Bush) banana republic politics, the New York parking space shortage even for Christian martyrs, those rumours about J. Edgar Hoover, the politics of Miss America, Jewish neuroses, the dearly departed authority of Howard Cosell and his Wide World of Sports, etc. Every Allen film records its cultural moment for posterity.
To his further credit, though the surface is period-specific his themes continue to resonate. All those typewriters in Manhattan (1979) suggest a pre-computer world as remote as Mars, but Isaac Stern’s (Allen) moral lesson and questionable conduct challenge us still.
Marxist guerilla leader in Woody Allen’s Bananas (Jack Rollins & Charles H. Joffe Productions, 1971).103
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
page3image1756128
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Boris: Father: Boris: Father: Boris:
He must have been Possessed.
Well, he was 
A Raw Youth.
Raw Youth
! He was an Idiot ... I hear he was a Gambler.You know, he could be your Double.
Really. How novel.
Historical Comedy on Screen
As well as writing history Allen quotes it, especially the past of his medium. Sometimes this takes the form of allusions. The mechanical tasting job in Bananas parodys Chaplin’sModern Times (1936). In Love and Death (1975) his coitally collapsing lions reverse the arousal of Eisenstein’s in Battleship Potemkin (1925). Allen ratchets up the brow for a dialogue based on Russian classic literature:
In Crimes and Misdemeanors (1989) he engaged Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment on a more serious level, exploring the same themes of murder, guilt and retribution in a godless order.
In fact, Allen learned to make films by parodying popular genres, from What’s up, Tiger Lily (1966) and Take the Money and Run (1969) through his anthology, Everything You Wanted to Know about Sex (1972). He became a filmmaker by engaging with the films of the past. In his maturity he embraced the spirits of his major models, Ingmar Bergman – inInteriors (1978), A Midsummer Night’s Sex Comedy (1982), Hannah and Her Sisters (1986) – and Federico Fellini – in Zelig (1983), The Purple Rose of Cairo (1985), Radio Days (1987) – with their dialectical synthesis in Stardust Memories (1980). Both in his experiments with the language of film and in his more ambitious later works Allen drew upon the film tradition, its history and its masterworks. This is rather more than the individual talent ransacking tradition. His continuing penchant for black and white and for classical jazz scoring confirms his classicism in form and in values.
When he made a period (historical) film, whether looking back – as in Love and Death,Radio Days and Zelig – or ahead – as in Sleeper (1973) – comedic anachronisms root the films in Allen’s present. ‘If God is testing us, why doesn’t He give us a written?’ A 200-year sleep is ‘like spending a weekend in Beverly Hills’. That is to say, the past – or the future – is not some other country or some other time but an organic part of our present. That concept validates the magical technology (aka gimmick) by which in Zelig Allen puts himself into a black jazz band of the 1920s, in the batting order behind Babe Ruth and on platform parties with Pope Pius XI (who swats him with a sacred text) and with Hitler (who oddly does not). History is not where we were but where we are. If we don’t understand that we can’t know ourselves or how we should live.
The sense of history becomes a persistent self-referentiality in Allen’s later films. For all the seriousness of Crimes and Misdemeanors – his monumental meditation upon faith, guilt, responsibility, moral blindness and our slippery slide from casual misdemeanour into a crime as serious as murder – Allen leavens his ostensibly comic subplot with self-references. His character, Cliff Stern, apparently a descendant of his Isaac Stern of Manhattan, is a
104
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Forms of History in Woody Allen
page5image1762176
Woody Allen’s period comedies: The Purple Rose of Cairo (Orion Pictures Corporation, 1985) and Radio Days (Orion Pictures Corporation, 1987).
105
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
page5image1761952
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Historical Comedy on Screen
pretentious Lefty documentary filmmaker who loathes his brother-in-law Lester (Alan Alda), a brilliant but amoral TV producer. Stern is appalled when Lester wins and weds the kindred spirit Halley Reed (Mia Farrow), for whom Stern planned to leave his wife.
As his name confirms, Stern is the familiar Allen nebbish/idealist. But he hardly comes near the saintly Rabbi Ben (Sam Waterson) as the film’s moral centre. Stern’s moral blindness registers in his harshness toward his sister’s suffering, his insensitivity to his wife’s needs and his increasingly irresponsible instruction of his young teen niece. Encouraging her to play hooky to see old films may be bad enough, but worse is when he unloads his plan for an adulterous affair with Halley. His animosity towards Lester proves both unfair to the generous and accomplished man and destructive of his own career.
Allen studs this storyline with allusions to his earlier films. The collapse of the weddingkasatzky repeats a gag in Love and Death. He dresses his niece as a miniature Annie Hall. Halley departs for England with the same two-shot, dynamic and even reassuring phrasing as Mariel Hemingway’s in Manhattan. Allen’s ironic injection of film clips – like his Stern’s newsreel Mussolini footage in his biopic of Lester – recalls his characters living through films from What’s up Tiger Lily (1966) and Play It Again, Sam (1972) to Zelig and Hollywood Ending (2002).
So why does Allen resurrect his old gags? The answer lies in the film’s central scene, Judah Rosenthal’s (Martin Landau) memory of a childhood family seder. There the debate between rational scepticism and faith concludes that whatever our belief in a god we are defined by all the choices we make through our life. This explains Judah’s guilt over the murder of his mistress Dolores (Anjelica Huston).
In that light, Allen’s recycled jokes (aka self-referential allusions) are how the auteur defines himself by the specific choices he has made all his life/career. However heroic or ignoble our pretences or our self-conception, we are only what we have done. We are our history. Allen tempers his most sombre exercise in philosophy with these reminders of his comic past. This modesty plays against his Stern’s unearned superiority and Judah’s massive hypocrisy. It coheres with the blind rabbi’s humility and even the gangster Jack’s (Jerry Orbach) saving grace: Unlike successful brother Judah, Jack does not forget his obligations. As well, the reminders of Allen the film director encourage us to detach the director from the character actor Allen plays.
Of course, Allen’s film career was seriously disrupted by the scandal involving his private life with Mia Farrow and her allegations about his relationship with their children, especially her then twenty-one-year-old stepdaughter, Soon-Yi Previn, with whom he was having an affair. The famed moralist’s scandalous behaviour was as disillusioning and career-threatening as the notorious Fatty Arbuckle’s had been. It is difficult to read any Allen film of this period – from Husbands and Wives (1992) through Hollywood Ending (2002) – without taking that scandal into account, whether his statement seems a form of address – Deconstructing Harry(1997), Celebrity (1998) – or of avoidance – Manhattan Murder Mystery (1993), Small Time Crooks (2000).
106
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Forms of History in Woody Allen
Indeed, when his personal scandal undercut the moral ambition of his films Allen turned to exercise the innocence of classic genre entertainments, as in Manhattan Murder Mystery, the superior Bullets over Broadway (1994) and the antique musical Everyone Says I Love You (1996), and the lesser Small Time Crooks and Curse of the Jade Scorpion (2001). By turning to the film history he could set aside his own. His retreat included two zipless revivals for television, his own Don’t Drink the Water (1994) and Neil Simon’s The Sunshine Boys (1995).
In his nostalgic genre plots Allen dramatized the revival of a waning relationship – or converting an instinctive antagonism into love. In these simpler entertainments Allen considers the values required to regenerate a relationship. A character’s/artist’s fidelity to an old cultural form reflects a personal honour. This theme is reversed in his best film of this period, Sweet and Lowdown (1999), where the mechanics of the musical biopic anatomize a disintegrating psyche. Still, the public structure of a genre provides an apparently innocent, impersonal form for a fiction.
The Innocent Genre series ended with Hollywood Ending, where Allen mercifully reverted to his more acidic/Hasidic view of Lotus Land. The film still conveys Allen’s love for Old Hollywood movies and his loathing for the current Hollywood culture (an oxymoron, like ‘agent ethics’). The failed film director Val Waxman (Allen, striving against his waning career) directs a film despite mysteriously going blind. His terrible film proves a huge success in France – as Ending did at Cannes – and wins back Val’s ex-wife, Ellie (Tea Leoni). By sweeping her out of Hollywood to their ‘unfulfilled life dream’, Paris, Val effects the rescue Alvy Singer couldn’t in Annie Hall. In a satiric version of Allen reworking old themes, a Hollywood hack remakes a ‘stupid potboiler’.
Unlike Purple Rose of Cairo and Zelig films-within-films, we don’t see any footage from Val’s The City That Never Sleeps. But we hear symptomatic crashes. We don’t know how it’s bad or how it might be taken to be good. But auteurism – like other religions – requires faith
Between fiction and documentary: Zelig(Orion Pictures Corporation, 1983).
107
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
page7image1764640
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Historical Comedy on Screen
in the maker. The blind Val may well have made ‘the best American film in 50 years’ (as the French critics claim), and Val may indeed be a genius who thrives on chaos, like Fellini.
Two acrid satires marked an ambitious recess from Allen’s sequence of genre entertainments and a return to his own history. In the first, Deconstructing Harry (1997), Harry Block (Allen) is a successful novelist who controversially mined his life for his fiction – like Philip Roth, who at the time was Mia Farrow’s love interest. Block’s representation in his novel is played by Richard Benjamin, who starred in the film of Roth’s Goodbye Columbus (1969). About to be honoured by the university that expelled him (‘I tried to give the dean’s wife an enema’), Harry is arrested for kidnapping his own son. He violated his visitation conditions so his son could share the experience. In Block Allen admits a view of himself as a goof more sinned against sinning. Something of his sense of injustice comes through a rejected mistress’s rage at ‘retarded talkshow hosts’ and even artists who take ‘everyone’s suffering and turn it into gold’.
The second recess is Celebrity (1998) which draws its meaning by its scene-by-scene parallels to and divergence from Fellini’s La Dolce Vita (1960). In this replay of a jaded celebrity journalist’s tour of the culture’s sordid glitz, several jokes involve the idea of history and film. One young actor is making ‘an adaptation of a sequel of a remake’. The new film leeches on the past, but sans discrimination. The Mastroianni figure Lee (Kenneth Branagh) has imagined one temptress as ‘the obscure object of desire’, a Buñuel film title (1977). The film producer plans to remake ‘Birth of a Nation – an all-black version’. As the original D.W. Griffith film is a classic of racism, valorizing the Ku Klux Klan, the improbable project exposes the producer’s ignorance of the very film he presumes to revive. Indeed, Celebrityitself mobilizes history. The theme of seductive celebrity is expressed in the classic song over the opening credits – ‘You Oughta Be in Pictures’. In context, that love song shrinks to an exhortation to join the shallow world of the Image. In the closing song Billie Holiday alludes to history: ‘Did I Remember?’ Like its characters, this film does not exist isolated in the present but is defined by its awareness of and response to its past.
Not having recovered his pre-scandal status, Allen left not just his haunting New York but America for three films set and shot in England – Match Point (2005), Scoop (2006) andCassandra’s Dream (2007) – and one in Gaudi’s wild Spain, Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008). The films replayed Allen’s familiar themes of romantic quest, guilt and betrayal, in other cultural landscapes.
The entire weight of Allen’s troubled personal history comes to rest upon even the title of his Whatever Works (2009). In casting Larry David as the central nebbish/loser Allen engages the most prominent current figure in the vein of Jewish-American self-satirists that Allen effectively founded.
Boris Yelnikoff (David) is Allen’s most outrageous misanthrope. He leaves his perfect wife Jessica (Carolyn McCormick) because ‘On paper we’re ideal. But life isn’t on paper’. His consequent suicide leap leaves him limping. Having abandoned his physics professorship he ekes out a living ‘teaching chess to incompetent zombies’. His story insists ‘You’ve got to take what little pleasures you can find in this chamber of horrors’. History has taught Boris that people are essentially terrible. When he marries the very young vagrant Melodie St Ann
108
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Forms of History in Woody Allen
Celestine (Evan Rachel Wood), they are ‘two runaways from the vast, black, unspeakably violent and indifferent universe’. The theme song of Boris’s first two marriages is ‘If I Could Be with You (one hour tonight)’, an explicit gesture against the abyss of eternity.
At seventy-three Allen seems prompted to spell out as clearly and explicitly as he can his one most compelling theme and lesson. The song over the opening credits sets the valedictory tone: Groucho Marx’s ‘Hello I Must Be Going’. Not just the film but his whole career is boiled down to the title. In his world of accident, brutality, callousness, moral chaos and social conventions that however idealistic can strangle the individual spirit, people must do ‘whatever works’.
The misanthrope’s moral slogan catches on. Against Boris’s predictions for these ‘family values morons’, the whole Celestine family from the bathetic, post-lapsarian Eden, Mississippi, find fulfilment in New York. Melodie finds her true love – outside her marriage to Boris. Her mother Marietta (Patricia Clarkson) discovers her own creative powers – in photography, recalling Annie Hall – and finds fulfilment in an arty ménage-a-trois. Marietta’s wayward NRA husband John (Ed Begley Jr) frees his natural homosexuality and settles into an antique business with Howard Cummings nee Kaminsky (Christopher Evan Welch). Even Boris finds fulfilment in Helena (Jessica Hecht), the psychic on whom he fell on his second post-marital suicide leap. This takes him out of his neurotic insularity, as emblematized by his singing ‘Happy Birthday’ to himself when he washes his hands, to avoid germs.
The Purple Rose of Cairo (Orion Pictures Corporation, 1985).109
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.
page9image1726784
Copyright © 2011. Intellect Books Ltd. All rights reserved.
Historical Comedy on Screen
In the first scene Boris criticizes religion for having become corporate and for assuming people are essentially good. ‘People make life so much worse than it has to be.’ Against social conventions, the film justifies affairs December–June, adulterous, homosexual. Allen reiterates the overriding lesson of the Isaac-Tracy romance in Manhattan and the universal moral requirement of love in Crimes and Misdemeanors: Whatever works.
One joke fugitively alludes to Allen’s notorious affair with Soon-Yi Previn. Trying to persuade Melodie to return home to Mississippi, Boris warns ‘You’ll wind up a prostitute like those Asian girls who come here full of high hopes and wind up prostitutes, turning tricks to keep alive. And many of them are actually good looking’ – unlike Melodie, ‘a three’. But Melodie wins her shelter: ‘If you throw me out and I wind up an Asian prostitute, that’s gonna be on your conscience.’ While Allen’s scandal has been left in the dust by the success of that relationship, the reference confirms the confluence of Allen’s life and his art.
Like the film character’s address to the movie audience in Annie Hall and throughoutPurple Rose of Cairo, Boris from the first scene on addresses the film audience that he sees and that the other characters don’t. To Boris this proves he alone has ‘the big picture’. He alone knows he is living a fiction. His film-awareness redoubles Boris’s dismissal of moral absolutes as but fictional constructs. Hence his disdain for social convention – ‘Charm has never been a priority with me’ – as for religions and social restrictions upon relationships.
Allen’s history both on screen and off culminate in the bleak heartiness of this film’s resolution. In a heartless universe we can find meaning and love only in each other, so whatever the laws and conventions, go for ... whatever works. Otherwise history will dissolve us before our time has come.
110
Historical Comedy On Screen : Subverting History with Humour, edited by Hannu Salmi, Intellect Books Ltd, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ucalgary-ebooks/detail.action?docID=711691.
Created from ucalgary-ebooks on 2018-06-25 17:16:12.

Les Guardiennes

The title is inadequately translated. The English “Guardians” is gender neutral. The French “Guardiennes” is explicitly feminine. 
That’s the point. This film, a noble return to the classic French narrative style, exalts the role women played during WW I, not just running the family farm but in preserving the family unit, the larger social structure and civilized values. 
As the first two shots explain, the men are off dead and dying on the battlefield. Meanwhile, back on the farm, it’s the matriarch Hortense pushing the plow behind the overworked mare.
The rural beauty of France stands in implicit contrast to the violent destruction wreaked in the war. 
While the school kids learn a poem about the inhumanity of the Bosch (translation: Krauts), a returning soldier shares his contrary wisdom: the enemy German soldiers were just like their enemy French, simple ordinary folk thrown into a conflict neither of their making nor of their will or understanding. But the deaths and dread and nightmares roll on. 
The film’s noblest soldier is Francine, the orphan girl Hortense hires to help in the harvest but who works her way into a permanent position with the family. That is, until their son Georges and she fall in love, threatening Hortense’s control. 
For being a responsible, even heroic guardian is not enough. What’s crucial is the values being guarded.  
Despite her affection and respect for Francine, Hortense lies about her virtue to dissuade son Georges from marrying her. She comes from nobody, she explains, with whoredom in her blood. Later Hortense refuses to tell Georges Francine is carrying his child. 
Thus Hortense meets what she sees her responsibility to maintain the family honour — letting Francine carry the guilt that daughter Solange has provoked — and  to consign George to marry his drab childhood friend Marguerite. That's a severely compromised "honour."
At this point the film’s domestic theme expands into French values, even European, indeed the entire Western Civilization that both World Wars ostensibly defended. Killing and dying for one’s values may be a fine virtue — but that depends on the values. And whether the values defended in war are sustained in peacetime.
The heroes’ martial valour is undercut by Hortense’s inhumanity both to her son and to his lover. She betrays her dutiful servant out of class snobbery, an exalted vanity and her need to keep control over her family. 
When she glimpses her unacknowledged grandchild, Hortense briefly realizes the horrible costs of her misdeed, even to herself. But she makes no amends. It’s too late or her strength has left her too weak to undo the damage she did the son she thought she was protecting and the woman who served her so faithfully..   
There’s a sting in the tail at the end of the narrative. The eldest son back from the war, the farm thriving and modernized thanks to the women’s initiative, the men fall to arguing over the division of the estate. The war briefly unified the men that can’t live in peace at home. 
The only harmony and cheer are provided by the triumphant and resourceful Francine. Raising her child on her own, she’s now also a locally successful singer, still brightening her world, though alone. 
       Poor Georges in the audience is still enchanted by her and will never understand his loss. He returned wounded from the war but emotionally crippled by his mother’s betrayal. He won the continental war but lost the domestic battle.

Saturday, June 23, 2018

First Reformed

Like Reverend Toller’s diary, this film is Paul Schrader’s form of prayer. It’s an attempt to find meaning, purpose and integrity in our fallen world. Our religion has been compromised by worldiness, our faith engulfed by despair. 
Its religious core is Thomas Merton’s insight: despair and hope are equally valid, indeed interdependent visions. Wisdom inheres in the ability to hold two such contrary ideas in the mind at the same time. Either without the other is incomplete, inadequate, futile.
Like the green activist Michael (an echo of the avenging angel), Reverend Toller’s idealism leads to paralysis by despair. Toller can’t rebut Michael’s arguments about man’s abandonment of nature, of God in His world. He can only repeat Michael’s question; “Can God forgive us for what we have done to His world?” 
Toller is himself guilt-ridden for having sent his son off to death in the Iraq war. That broke Toller’s marriage, his self-respect and his faith. Because of his feeling of futility, when Michael’s wife Mary comes for help Toller’s first impulse is to refer her to the more affluent super church nearby. Her persistence and Michael’s suicide reawaken Toller’s passion for God. But now it’s in the form of trying to protect His creation instead of the formalities of the church. Toller’s plan to blow himself up at the church’s reconsecration is his personal reconsecration to the proper service of God, to try saving His world from its corrupt abusers. 
The plot chronicles the reverend’s progression from mechanically serving his dying church to rediscovering the proper function of religion — compassion and love. 
His brief affair with (the faithful) Esther only stirred his lust, which he now admits he despises both in her and in himself. His feelings for Mary (the pure) grow slowly and more profoundly. Planning to sacrifice himself at his church’s reconsecration, he demands she stay away. Her appearance aborts his plan because he can’t inflict on her another sacrifice, his suicide after her husband’s.  
Toller’s and Mary’s love develops across two scenes of intense physical engagement There he assumes Michael’s mission both politically and personally, in environmentalism and in his relationship with Mary. That combination is religion. Toller becomes the avenger Michael.
In the first he obliges her request to replay her and Michael’s Magical Mystery Tour. She lies flat on him on the floor, arms and hands extended so their bodies touch as much as they can, their eyes locked and moving together as they breathe together. 
The sexual potential of that posture instead turns into a transcendental vision. They float off the floor, soar through the world into heaven (at least, the starry skies) — but then back into the sordid evidence of man’s ruin of God’s creation. That experience inspires Toller’s obsessive resolve to sacrifice himself in protest against the world’s corruption. 
Their full union occurs when she comes to him from the reconsecration ceremony he is missing. Their clench and kiss overwhelm both. He has just wrapped himself in barbed wire, to atone for his dashed resolve. He bleeds through his vestments. In that act he assumes the function of Jesus, suffering himself for the sins of mankind. But at the appearance of Mary he turns himself instead into Michael. in the woman for whom he first felt compassion and whose tragic loss he both shared and assuaged, Toller finds his full religious service — love. 
At that point the film just stops. The end is shocking. It seems incomplete — indeed like the end of the last episode of that other American epic of contemporary secular calvary, The Sopranos. Is there a technical problem here? we instinctively ask.
But of course that is Schrader’s point. The couple’s realized love is all either needs. The proper service to God is to mankind. The most compelling faith is human love. With that they can confront their despair, their faith and connection deepened, and stand to defend God’s world against corrupt and corrupting man. 
Schrader stops the film without the comfort of a standard ending because its proper ending lies in us. As Toller accepted Michael’s mission, his passes on to us. 
That’s the point of Michael’s funeral requests. Instead of the traditional hymn —such as the one Esther sings so archly, so unconnectedly — Toller grants Michael’s request for a Neil Young ecology hymn. Love and reverence need an active voice.
The film shares Toller’s asceticism. Like his stark, sparsely finished quarters, the film is stripped down. The classic square screen proportion is a harsh shrinkage of our more familiar widescreen. The buildings are flat, symmetrical, stern frames. Most scenes are stripped of colour and the relief of any music, other than what the characters bring the scene. 
Toller’s self-loathing leads to his Calvinist church’s self-denial. His breakfast is an apparent gruel, spiked with whiskey, scooped up in hunks of bread. A break into a sushi dinner proves a revelation of what life he is missing.  
For all the film’s asceticism, though, poetry abounds. Toller declines Michael’s offer of a drink, not because he’s not “a drinking man” but because he’s a drinking priest — and ”It doesn’t help.” Pouring Pepto into his scotch produces a shot of a swirl of pollution where the values of purity and survival seem mutually and inextricably compromised. 
Toller’s physical suffering fleshes out his spiritual. He has a cancer. His painful and bleeding urination evokes the constipated Martin Luther’s composed eruption. His plumbing is shot, as we learn from his leaking hot water faucet, his plugged toilet and his own vomiting. This motif confirms the tension in man’s amphibian nature, a troubled soul lumbered with a troubling body, the holy grounded in the secular.
The hero’s name evokes John Donne’s reflection on the bell announcing another death: “Ask not for whom the bell tolls. It tolls for thee.” This reverend is our toller. 
In its intelligence, high seriousness, emotional effect and quality of realization I’d call this the best American feature film of the year. Okay, so far. 
It is also disturbingly but bracingly timely. Released into the days of thousands of imprisoned children, slandered immigrants, betrayed asylum seekers, a burgeoning fascism, a corporate stranglehold on the government, the suicidal EPA and the tragically compromised religious Right, this film strikes straight to the heart.
 

Tuesday, June 19, 2018

Die Hard (reprint)

Die Hard
The white man's mythic invincibility

by Maurice Yacowar
from Jump Cut, no. 34, March, 1989, pp. 2-4
copyright Jump Cut: A Review of Contemporary Media, 1989, 2006 

     Though the box-office success of John McTiernan's DIE HARD is primarily due to its breakneck action, it may also be striking a popular nerve in its reactionary politics. When the ruggedly individualist hero thwarts a terrorist takeover of an L.A. office tower, he lives out a macho pipedream on two political fronts, the international and the sexual.
     In Los Angeles for Christmas, New York cop John McClane (Bruce Willis) meets his separated wife, Holy Gennero McClane (Bonnie Bedelia), at her office party in the Century-City and Fox Towers. The building is taken over by a highly-institutionalized terrorist group, faintly suggestive of the Baeder-Meinhof group in Germany. McClane fights a guerrilla war against the terrorists. Despite the intervention of the police force, FBI and television reporters, McClane eventually overcomes the terrorists and is reunited with his wife.
     In terms of international politics, McClane exercises the mythic invincibility of the U.S. individualist. Not only is he out of his element, a N.Y. cop in L.A., but he is a reject/misfit in his separated wife's world. He wears working class among the designer silk suits. But he exploits his nature as an outsider. His separateness - for a close shave - saves him from the terrorists' initial sweep, enabling him to wage his war. From the chief terrorist's sneer at the cowboy heroic, McClain adopts the nom de guerre Roy (as in Rogers but also - as we shall see vis-á-vis women - as in King).
      At its simplest this is a reflexive escalation of the first Rambo film, First Blood, which replayed the Viet Nam war in a small U.S. town. The L.A. battle graphically evokes Nam. There's the spectacle of swooping and suddenly rising military helicopters. The terrorists deploy such sophisticated weaponry as an anti-tank rocket. The glossy building is reduced to rubble; specifically, McClane rushes through the indoor garden that has been turned into a reeking jungle. So too his strategy has him belly-crawling and swinging through the skeleton of the building, the air vents and elevator shafts, as if he were engaged in jungle warfare.      This metaphor - Coppola out of Conrad - discovers the jungle at the heart of the L.A. slick.      That's also the implication of his fighting barefoot, bleeding from the deliberately shattered glass (the unsympathetic environment) and shifting from white undershirt to combat green.    At one point McClane must duck FBI bullets (the "friendly lire" of Nam). The FBI are also prepared to accept the massive loss of "civilian" hostages to effect their textbook "rescue."        Indeed one attacking FBI officer (Robert Davi) even gloats "Just like fuckin' Saigon" - as indeed it will prove in his military failure. The abundance of "Johnsons" in the FBI delegation locates the assault in the context of Lyndon (as in Mel Brooks's version of the Johnson County wars in Blazing Saddles). Finally, as a New York City cop in Los Angeles, McClane assumes a moral authority outside his precinct (another Beverly Hills Cop), as if his movable authority were by necessity valid in alien terrain.
     More profoundly, this plot attempts to deny the hard reality of the United States' failure in that war. The Rambo and Chuck Norris series have well established the commercial viability of such revisionism.
     To conceal the film's denial of Viet Nam, the villains are drawn from broader traditions. The chief killers are two Aryan brothers, who evoke the Hollywood Nazi. Karl (Alexander Godunov) proves even more of a die-hard than the hero - or his dinosaur macho ethic. Their colleagues include an apparent Japanese, a wisecracking black (of whom more later), two Italians and more Germans. The leader is a sophisticated business-type (the post-war Nazi?) Hans Gruber (Alan Rickman). He disguises the greed of his mission (objective: $640,000,000 in bonds) in clichés of third-world radical politics. With tongue-in-cheek the villain demands the initial release of a variety of "political" prisoners, his "comrades in arms" from Ireland, Quebec and Sri Lanka (the latter cited from Time). Thus the film reduces the concept of freedom fighter (or even terrorist) to a greedy hypocrite, in effect denying the validity of any non-U.S. crusader.
     In the hero's isolation the film by implication draws upon common rationalizations for the United States's loss in Viet Nam. The myth assumes that the indomitable, just U.S. soldier could only lose a war through sabotage. Here the local police are ensnarled in red tape (the hero is scolded for calling on an emergency channel). Deputy Police Chief Dwayne Robinson (Paul Gleason) is not just mean but always dead wrong. The FBI proves even more unwieldy and treacherous.
     The second institutional scapegoat is the ever-reliable Media. An unscrupulous newsman (William Atherton) endangers the hero and his hostage wife by exposing their children on TV. In context this replays the myth that the U.S. lost in Viet Nam because of television's irresponsible exposures. There is a civilian fifth-column counterpart to the journalist: a self-serving executive, Ellis (Hart Bochner), reveals McClane's identity to the terrorist.
     The film also seems studied in its xenophobia. Gruber is triply negative because he is a German thief, British-educated and cultured. The occupied office is already suspect because it now belongs to a Japanese company. The country lost its Pearl Harbor attempt so it's now coming with tape decks, the president quips. The audience is set up to relish the demolition of the posh tower because it represents foreign ownership, the clutch of transnational megacapitalism, which makes the individualist's rescue all the more satisfying. The victim company is also contaminated with high culture, what with a string quartet performing at the Christmas party and a Degas stashed in the vault.
     Even more condescendingly, the film plays all its blacks for laughs. One black cop comically pricks himself on a rosebush. The film's one super-intelligent black, gang member Theo (Clarence Gilyard Jr.), has the most technological skill and cleverness but he personifies play. He raps about basketball to set up the first murder ("Two points!"). As he makes a game of everything, he represents ability spoiled by amorality. Here we have an upscale version of the "shuck'n'jivin" black character of yore.
     McClane is aided by two blacks outside the tower, but both are introduced as comic figures and allowed only dubious redemptions at the end. The young chauffeur Argyle [Devoreaux White) is Theo's opposite number, a cocky streetwise black who misses the early chances to act because he's lost in his four-wheel stretch ghetto-blaster. In his style-pretentious name and in the glories of his lavish limo, Argyle represents the young black of larger style than merit. He's the over-dressed buffoon. When he finally acts it is in a simple, brutish reflex that smashes the luxury he has been (undeservedly?) enjoying. Ironically, the untalented Argyle thwarts the technological, experienced but corrupt Theo. That is, U.S. innocence bests worldliness. That happens every time out, except perhaps in reality.
     McClane's chief support is the middle-aged, portly black cop who first responds to the alarm, then by his CB conversation sustains a spiritual lifeline to McClane. Sgt. Al Powell (Reginald Veljohnson) is introduced as a comic stereotype, loading up on Twinkies for his pregnant wife. But he grows to provide a human alternative to the textbook deputy Robinson. Powell is so sensitive that he has refused to fire a gun since he accidentally killed an innocent 13-year old. But the film does not allow this sensitivity to stand. As if liberated by McClane's example, Powell overcomes his (neurotic) sensitivity to kill again. (The audience dutifully applauds.) It is also given to Powell to correct McClane's estranged wife: "You've got yourself a good man. You take good care of him." Thus Powell is allowed to transcend his initial comedic register, but only to deliver retrograde macho.
     Powell's advice to McClane's wife defines the sexual politic in the Die Hardpipedream. The couple is separated because the woman has presumed to move West to pursue her brilliant business career, while her husband chooses to fight New York crime. Although she manages home and career superbly, the film subtlely condemns her for abandoning her husband. The implication is that she is wrong to stand by an additional man, as she serves her boss. The Christmas setting amplifies Holly's violation of family sentiment, especially as it means celebrating the winter fest in balmy (both senses) L.A. (where the only snow off the soundtrack is up Ellis's nose).
     Here is the pipedream: McClane's adventure provides him with the opportunity to correct his wife. He demonstrates that she cannot survive without him; she needs him to look after her. The TV exposure even proves that she cannot escape her married name. At first she used her maiden name at work out of respect for her boss's traditions; she reaffirms her married identity at the end. In her climactic rescue McClane sends Gruber to his death by undoing the expensive watch on Holly's wrist. In an early scene that Rolex was introduced as her company's reward to her for a spectacular business success. The symbolism is clear: McClane saves his wife by stripping her of the emblem of her success. In bringing her down from her tower he saves her from her vulnerability, her success, in a word, her independence. The film speaks potently to and for men who have lost their protective power over their women. Holly's last aggression is wholly within the traditional role of woman: she slugs the newscaster who violated her family's privacy.
     Consistent with the film's demeaning of woman are the passing bits of gratuitous sexism. McClane catches the stewardess's eye. He glances at overstretched tights at the airport and an undressed woman in the next tower. He ritually pats a pin-up by the power panel. This sexist is a man's man. He laughs off a man's kiss at the party.
     The casting of Bruce Willis confirms the film's sexist ethos. From his first scene, anxious in an airplane, Willis draws upon his bathetic, mock-heroic persona from the airwaves, David Addison of MOONLIGHTING. He plays roughly the same character here, wise-cracking even when he's alone. In the TV series the light characterization and self-reflexivity undermine his macho pretensions and authority. But the larger-screen epic allows them unquestioned sprawl. Willis's heroic role here contrasts sharply to his ironic roles in his two Blake Edwards films, BLIND DATE and SUNSET. DIE HARD could be David Addison's pipedream, wreaking a largescreen vengeance unallowed in his small-screen reality and reaffirming a male dominance over woman that his "real" (i.e., MOONLIGHTING) persona lacks.
     The open appeal of DIE HARD lies in its snappy wit and crisp action. But it has a deeper appeal in its political assumptions, which speak to the sexist who craves to have his obsolete delusions reaffirmed.

Monday, June 18, 2018

Let the Sunshine In

By now we expect a Clare Dennis movie to be a stylish, incisive anatomy of French cultural or political traditions (aka cliches). Here she deploys romance queen Juliette Binoche as a passionate beauty moving relentlessly through a series of unfulfilling affairs. The film targets France's current decay into an amoral, self-destructive shallowness. 
Isabelle is a successful painter, specifically an abstract expressionist. In the one work we see she splashes broad black strokes across a floored white canvas, hoping her sweeping slashes will discover and express a passion she has nowhere — or no-one — else for it to go. She seeks in that formless chaos a meaning and beauty in revolt against traditional orderliness.    
     That’s in love as in her art. In her search for someone in whom to invest her ardor she chooses poorly — the selfish, insulting married banker, the equally shallow married actor, the comically silent and vulpine labourer she meets in a dance. Her conversations are a cover under which she hides, hoping to pounce on the one physical connection that will sustain and absolve her. Except for the labourer, her dates sink into wordy chats that are meaningless, empty parodies of a connection.
     We see her painting only once. So she seems to be only playing at the role of the romantic artist — and in an almost obsolete genre at that.
At first Isabelle easily commands our sympathy, our identification. But the sequence of her brittle affairs steadily shifts her from model to warning. As she moves through the variously unappealing men, as we watch her emotional rollercoaster, we see her as a compulsive dependent, whose modern sexual freedom only restricts self-discovery and prevents lasting satisfaction. 
She proves a selfish mother, a mercurial ex-wife, and variously unsupportive or unfaithful to her lovers, all under the cover of her own needs and special sensitivity. In admission of her self-disrespect, Isabelle admits she got an orgasm with the banker only by focusing on how disgusting he is. Yet she told him she loves him. 
As her every sexual conquest only deepens her isolation, Isabelle’s whole society is a satire of modern French culture. The genial but foppish neighborhood suitor who invites her to the country only provokes her explosion at bourgeois complacency, especially as it romanticizes their Nature. But from her attack on that cliche she only moves on to act another one out herself—picking up the labourer at the bar.    
Isabelle’s romances here form a critique of French sexual indulgence, especially in its cinema, which has long cornered the world market on free love. Hence the climactic appearance of French icon Gerard Depardieu at the end. In his first scene he appears — at first unidentifiable — with an unfamiliar woman on a date. He dismisses her. That is, he replays Isabelle’s hunger for a romantic connection, futilely searching for completion in yet another stranger.
In the next scene he’s revealed as Isabelle’s ostensible therapist — but he’s just a psychic! Aka quack. As he spews his intuitions about her various men she brightens in hope. But he’s only picking up on her responses to deliver what she wants to hear. 
Long the bad boy of French romantic cinema, here Depardieu as a bloated charlatan spews pop psych cliches that only re-enforce Isabelle's deluded quest for romantic perfection. He urges her to be — not “ouverte” but the American pop — “open” to whatever temptation arises.  
     That’s not admitting the sunshine she craves, but reinforcing her darkness. While the credits scroll down the left side of the screen, Depardieu continues the shallow “insight” she needs to continue her pathetic delusions. His running on and on confirms the satiric function of Depardieu's role. 
Denis provides a rather negative range of characters here. Two men stand apart, the gallery colleague and friend who patiently waits her to return his love and the black man wise enough to insist on taking time to see whether a relationship will naturally develop between them. For a full, healthy relationship we only have Isabelle’s friend’s report that she and her Jacques are taking the time and trouble to work patiently on a demanding and therefore rewarding connection, over time. Without the artist’s license, they’ve moved from nomad to gardener.  

 

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

Book Club

The trouble with Book Club is that there really isn’t any book club. At all.
Our four heroines meet regularly to discuss a book — but they don’t. The only sessions we see are about the sequential secretions of 50 Shades of Grey. Even then, there are no discussions of idea, theme, style, anything literary. You know: book club stuff. 
Instead the “book club” sessions serve only as an excuse to launch the women’s respective sexual reawakenings. 
Understand, I’m all for 70-plus-year-olds having sex. Present company especially. I’m all for parents outgrowing their adult dependents and even addressing and amending old neuroses. 
I’m glad to see Jane Fonda, Candace Bergen, Mary Steenburgen and Diane Keaton dug out of mothballs and deployed against the industry’s obsession with youth. 
As for the men, Richard Dreyfuss, Don Johnson, Andy Garcia, all are welcome resurrections of our role models of yore — and Craig Nelson our more realistic reflection. It’s even gratifying to see Wallace Shawn revive the Fallback Homunculus role he’s played since Annie Hall. 
But why do all these mature women have to be reharnessed to the tired tread of sexual comedy? Why does a federal judge (Bergen) have to be reduced to bawdy embarrassment?  These actors and their characters are grown up now, so can’t they be characterized by their intelligence and  — dare one say? — ideas instead of assigned their old sex roles? 
Still, it’s a very funny movie. Wit abounds and the leads’ predicaments can be intermittently engaging. 
      But if you’re bringing back such intelligent, capable performers give them some meat, Leave the floss for their lessers. The young ones who haven't seen enough to do more. 

Hereditary

Annie is an artist who makes dioramas. Instead of preparing for her next show, though, she is obsessed with constructing miniatures of her current home life, from her daughter’s attic bedroom to the scene of her fatal road accident. 
The first of Annie’s delicately detailed boxes opens into her real world home. That means her real rooms seem to shrink into tight boxes, with constricting panelled hallways and oppressive beamed ceilings. 
More importantly, as son Peter discovers, the real narrative of his life is not what’s happening in his social, family and school existence, but on a higher plane altogether, where he is slated to serve a higher purpose. From that outside perspective his world shrinks to little boxes.  
In his school scenes dissections of classical tragedy, politics and economics seem to evaporate as Peter is drawn into his larger destiny.
The film is a kind of Rosemary’s Granny. The presiding demonic power is the grandmother whose obituary and funeral open the film.  A private, secretive, strong woman, she turns out to have been the high priestess of a satanic order. Her primary aide Joan is played by Ann Dowd, drawing on associations with her role as stern housemother in The Handmaid’s Tale. 
As the title suggests, we see three generations of witch hood. The priestess’s daughter Annie performs the necessary rituals and infernal sacrifices. For most of the film we read the psychodrama as Annie’s story, buffeted between two deaths, mother then daughter. She struggles to sustain maternal sensitivity. That’s where the film is most powerful, when it situates a nightmare danger in our centre of emotional connection, the mother.
When the drama shifts from family to cult, the key force becomes Annie’s daughter Charlie (granny’s favourite). She provides the spirit to be transferred into brother Peter’s body so he can rule as King Paimon. The girl’s androgynous name prepares for that transfer, as does her eerily otherworldly mien. As befits children innocently trapped in a larger destiny, Charlie and Peter both have severe problems breathing. 
Curiously, for a film that celebrates the supernatural power of women — a common terror among male filmmakers — the women end up needing a male to lead them, in body if not in spirit. Of course they first have to pound him into shape and inject the feminine spirit — but even that mythology worships the male. 
     Are we to find that reassuring?