Wednesday, July 11, 2018

Winter Hunt (Winterjagd)

The film’s last shot brings to darkened life the favourite painting Anselm earlier described. In the eponymous “Winter Hunt” a small hunched figure that stumbles through the cold field is both the hunter and the hunted. Lena’s splintering the frame prefigures her exposure of the old Nazi guard Anselm’s false history. She breaks the picture, then his story.
  Identifying with the painting, Anselm feels unfairly hunted by stories about his Auschwitz past. Lena turns out to be his new pursuer whom he briefly holds as his prey until her evidence pierces his defence. 
Anselm has studiously denied his past, in the face of trials and public persecution. Here Lena’s candid self-revelation forces him to confront his guilt and its poisonous hold over his family for 70 years. Exposed, he outs the old Nazi beast still within him. The little Jewish girls in the camp were flattered to be raped, he avers. So much for his indignation at being unfairly accused. 
Anselm initially dismisses Lena as a left-wing nut determined to persecute someone. Anyone. But her own story reiterates contemporary Germany’s ineluctable tie to its past, with its attendant, recurring responsibility. 
By confronting its historic evil, modern Germany recovers its moral compass. Confirming that bond, Lena initially introduces herself as Astrid, which is the name of wrier/director Astrid Schult. That makes both and the director’s and the character’s quest intensely personal. 
Housekeeper Elena is the serviceable, passive citizen, the righteous gentile, who serves what she takes to be the innocent victim. Unaware of the Jewish revenge, she brings a pork roast. The homonymous Lena and Elena are parallel outsiders. Where Lena confronts Anselm, Elena senses a problem but lets Maria turn her away from it. 
  Lena and Maria can also identify with the figure in the painting, both as Anselm's victims and as they hunt down their true origin and assume moral responsibility. On this, Maria follows the younger Lena.
  Maria is arguably the film’s moral centre. Her father’s lifelong faithful defender, she reluctantly admits the visitor and tends to her injury. That, like Anselm’s fate, is self-inflicted. When Maria injures herself in overcoming Lena, she extends her parallel. Lena’s certainty about Anselm’s guilt sets Maria finally to challenge her father’s self-serving version of history. 
     The film abounds with paradoxes. Here it's the Nazi cowering in fear and persecution while the Jew, Lena, lays siege and establishes the truth. The sterility of the Nazi cause is signified by Anselm never knowing he had a son, here losing his loyal daughter  and having his destiny sealed by his granddaughter.
     The shifting winds of German politics have only renewed this story’s compulsive currency -- and extended it through Europe. This very intense thriller was made for German TV, which would give its tight home setting an additional impact. Watching a home invasion at home is all the more chilling. Still, it’s a compelling cinema experience too.

Tuesday, July 10, 2018

The Last Suit

When Abraham, the 88-year-old Jewish tailor from Buenos Aires, arrives in Madrid he reveals he’s living King Lear’s folly. Decades earlier, when his favourite daughter Claudia (i.e., Cordelia) wouldn’t match her two older sisters in describing her love for him he disowned her, gave them his estate and refused to speak to her again. Having now unhoused him, the sisters doom him to a Home. He’s also at risk of losing a leg. Hence his oedipal limp. Indeed, he has named his right leg Tsures (yiddish for "troubles.").
Helpless and freshly robbed, he now reluctantly turns to Claudia for help. He squeezes out a strained apology for having so abused her. 
She corrects his story in one respect. The other sisters paid her her fair share after all. She gives him the grand he needs to get to Poland, but makes no effort to admit him into her — and her little daughter’s — life. There is none of Cordelia’s forgiveness, nor Lear’s reconnection.
But here’s the question: What the hell is a Lear rehash doing in a Holocaust survivor saga? 
It must be the heart of the film. It’s such a prominent jarring intrusion that it must bear the point of the exercise. 
Maybe the point is that the Lear echo is a famous story. Story-telling is a prominent early motif in the film. Abraham’s delightful, doomed little sister was enchanting in her capacity to invent stories and to share them with audiences. Her own story ends when the Nazis snatch her from Abraham’s grip. Not for her the immortality of the stars that she kept afloat in the night. 
So the film is about living through stories. After all — as has been remarked — the Holocaust is such a monstrous occurrence, with such unimaginable cruelty and an unfathomable scale of evil and inhumanity, that approaching its reality beggars the imagination.   
     How else deal with the unimaginable than by sending out stories that may at least point to its implications, however incompletely. What cannot be fathomed can perhaps be outlined or pointed to.
So this film is not so much the story of one survivor’s experience but a demonstration of how the extremities of history can only be approached in discrete fictions. The power of stories makes a history possible. That’s why the hero is named Abraham, the father of the Jewish people (as well as of the recycled Lear’s daughters) and why he’s that most stereotypical of Jews, the tailor. And the wanderer.
Though Abraham is 88 this is still a bildungsroman, a sequence of episodes through which the hero moves toward self-realization. Typically, the episodes stand quite separate. In the first, the sly grandfather negotiates a bribe with his even craftier granddaughter, to get a family photo to impress the old folks at the looming home. He then has a Kafkaesque scene with a travel agent in some shadowy warehouse. 
Subsequent scenes advance his mission but probably mean even more to the people he engages with. In passing he gives them stories to tell: the young music student on the plane, the hotel clerk who sings in a club, the German woman anthropologist whose Jewish history studies led to her learning yiddish. As they variously help him their scenes become dramatic tales to enrichen their bios. And lives. They all take their leave with warm, lingering embraces.
The main story is the reunion of the two old friends, the two tailors, at the end. They were so close as boys that when Abraham escaped from the Nazis, Piotrek fought off his own father in order to save their benefactor’s son. 
Though they have not communicated for over 60 years, and neither knows the other has survived, both men have such a need to complete their story that they recognize each other on sight. This film is less about life than about our need for stories.  
So, too, Abraham’s flashbacks whether in his dreams or his delirium. Especially the train  scenes seem culled from film-lore as much as from personal history or experience. 
Perhaps this theme is especially pertinent to a Holocaust survival film coming from Argentina. That country, after all, welcomed so many Nazi officials after the war. Of course it has a significant Jewish population now, but the history remains problematic. Jews have been attacked there, including a serious attack on a synagogue. Argentina was recently embarrassed when it buckled to Palestinian pressure and cancelled its national soccer team’s planned exhibition match in Tel Aviv. So the history — like the best stories — keeps retelling.  

Monday, July 9, 2018

Wajib

Palestinian writer/director Annemarie Jacir uses the male-bonding Road Movie genre to provide a cross-sectional survey of Christian Palestinians’ civilian life in Nazareth.  The focus on Christians here is striking because their life is far different from what we normally see depicted there. This is a comfortable, well-educated, successful community, though still chafing under Israeli control. 
As father and son hand-deliver invitations to the daughter’s wedding they recover warm memories — and revive old tensions. The father raises the son’s hackles with his reflexive sneer at a homosexual, his Old School moralism, his fibs of convenience.  
  Of course, even in this comfortable part of the troubled area if anything can go wrong it will. That includes the mistaken date on the printed invitations. A melee erupts when a motorist jumps the line at a gas station. Shadi’s fancy Italian shirt is the casualty.
As the father is a popular local teacher he’s well-known and respected in the community. But that comes at a cost too — his need to appease and even to befriend the Jewish watchdog in his school. The father is the family pragmatist. To comfort his neighbours he fibs about his son’s career, his unlikely return, his romantic commitment. 
That service is why the father stayed. On the phone he describes the superlative — and apparently mythic — beauties of the land, contrary to the visible evidence of broken neighbourhoods, amassed garbage, the general ruins. He has been living in the real Palestine, serving his family and the community, without the romanticism of any myth or cause. Hence the film’s title: Duty.
In contrast to his staying there to raise his two children, his wife wanted more than that life could give her. She abandoned her family to run off with a lover to America. Her eagerly-awaited return for her daughter’s wedding depends on her dying husband. The father stills feels her humiliation. 
Son Shadi similarly escaped the confines of his father’s life. He made a career in architecture and found a modern love in Italy. His lover and her family are more militant, the PLO. His father disdains of their lavish living abroad, the self-service and futility of their warfare and the amorality of his son’s relationship. His dignity lay in staying and serving his community at home, however that may have compromised him.
We hear about the school’s Jewish spy Ronnie and we see two Israeli soldiers enjoying felafel, but otherwise the film focuses on the Arab community. Several of the friends are Arab Christians, as we see from their decorated Christmas trees, the Santa market and the remarks about having “a winter wedding.” A neighbour worries about the growth of ISIS in the neighbourhood. 
We don’t often see such a spectrum of Arab life in the area. Hence the hosts’ offers of coffee segue into booze. One young girl, her family out, tries to seduce Shadi. His father’s old school-mate Georgette extends a similar invitation to him.
The cultural cross-section extends to the car radio. The father wants to play the old style traditional singer who will perform at the wedding. The son prefers the nostalgia of Procol Harum’s “Whiter Shade of Pale,” which collects additional irony from the earlier scene, when the father accidentally kills “an Israeli dog” — that’s white. A news report addresses the corruption charges against PM Netanyahu and his wife’s denials. Even on this spectrum of swarthy there’s the implication of white privilege. 
     Despite this careful structure and schematic, the subtleties in the performances, script and direction give this film the saving sense of life caught in the flow. It’s a rich glimpse into particular lives in a troubled place and time we more commonly experience from the larger stories in the headlines. 

Tuesday, July 3, 2018

To Dust

This wildly inventive black comedy declares its religious concerns in its three opening quotations. First two quotes share the screen: (i) the Kohelet assurance that upon death our body returns to its origin in dust and our spirit to God who gave it; (ii) Jethro Tull’s “God is an overwhelming responsibility.” The third — in response — is the framing Tom Waits ballad “Blow Wind Blow.”  Even apart from its valedictory lyrics, his rasping, indeed gravelly, voice is an emblem of the coarsened life due our rocky, dust-based corporeality. The wind he invokes is the ruach, the breath or spirit.
In short, the film is a Talmudic examination of the complex tension between body and soul, but in the contemporary vernacular: a Jethro Tull-mudic meditation. For the “overwhelming responsibility” of God necessarily falls upon man. “Shmuel” (or Samuel) means “he who hears God.”
Upstate New York Hassidic cantor Shmuel has trouble dealing with his wife Rivkah’s death from cancer. He can’t even make the ritual incision into his jacket lapel. 
Mainly he has nightmares about his wife’s decaying corpse. He sees her big toe explode. He is tormented by the suffering she must be feeling.  
Thirty days later, he can’t end his mourning period. So he launches a pseudo-scientific investigation into the process of a body’s decay. That is, he has lost the visceral belief that her true spiritual nature has escaped her body. 
In a comic replay of the theme, his two young sons believe their distracted father has been possessed by a dybbuk (who entered through his big toe). They try to exorcise the demon. 
On both levels the characters are concerned with the interconnection of the physical and the spiritual. Paradoxically, the boys appear to have the greater faith. For Shmuel’s obsessive empathy with Rivkah’s corpse suggests he can’t believe she’s already escaped her earthly body. His doubt disables his cantorial voice.
Through that lapse in faith, Shmuel’s quest leads him into a world of increasing secularity. It starts when the coffin seller, concluding that no possible sale is at risk, drops his reverent mien and starts conversationally to swear. From then on the dialogue hilariously pits the pious against the profane. That is, the world of the spirit dramatically collides with the dirt.
Shmuel’s orthodoxy is challenged again when he has to talk to the young woman at the community college, a dilemma he “solves” by writing her notes instead. 
Even this challenge pales before what follows when Shmuel suborns the reluctant college Biology teacher Albert to determine Rivkah’s current physical condition. Albert is teaching the need for an efficient eco-system. He trashes stuff in frustration with his class and his own mistakes. Shmuel’s intrusion grows from an irritation into his own obsession. 
Unlike Albert’s students, Shmuel acts on the teacher’s words, leading him into a sequence of profane actions, including the burial of one pig, the killing of another, the digging up of several dead, all debasing to the orthodox Jew, and all accompanied by the teacher’s verbal profanity. 
Shmuel’s degrading quest fails until the two men come upon a “body farm” where the recently deceased are held for study. Even here, they are initially frustrated by the system’s order, until they enter at night. Then Shmuel steals a glimpse of a body comparable to Rivkah’s. There he finds an assuring beauty. The system works.
The security guard who catches them finally unites the holy and the secular by their mutual inclusion. From her own family losses to cancer, she understands Shmuel’s needs so lets the men leave unarrested, uncharged. But most telling is her language: she is at once among the film’s most profane speakers and yet the most religious. She sends the Hassidic widower off with Jesus’s blessing.                               So what does God tell us through this Shmuel’s ordeal, quest and conclusion? Who knows?
     Perhaps that rituals help us deal with our most painful losses but may not in themselves be enough. A personal reconciliation may lie beyond the traditional forms and values. Perhaps our amphibian nature may require our engagement of the profane as well as the holy. The Lord may indeed move in miraculous ways His wonder to deform.  

Monday, July 2, 2018

On Chesil Beach

Ian McEwan’s screenplay for his own novel provides some fascinating examples of creative adaptation.
For example, the novel ends with Edward remembering Florence walking away from him till she is out of his sight. In the corresponding scene in the film the newlyweds stand at opposite ends of the screen with a cluttered rowboat between them. They speak across the abyss. As the raging Edward lets Florence walk away, the camera withdraws until Edward is left alone on his side of the screen. But the boat also sinks  out of sight, below the horizon. That is, his ship has sailed. The film adds a verbal/literary metaphor.
More dramatically, McEwan alters the ending by fleshing out Florence’s future and giving the couple a reunion that provides an emotional release — for the characters as well as  the audience. Edward’s closing remarks expand into an emotional scene that the screenplay adds to the novel. 
After a 50-year separation the erstwhile lovers independently fulfil their romantic pledges in the concert hall they ambitiously predicted. She plays the Mozart he could “sing;” he sits in C3. But more important than this literal realization, they finally find themselves in the same emotion, their love now tempered by regret. He weeps helplessly at the quintet’s standing ovation. Tears stream down Florence’s face, dramatizing the novel’s remark that at every performance she ruefully remembered him. 
The novel closes on Edward’s private remorse, his recognition that he ruined his life by his inaction when Florence walked away. They did love each other and perhaps could have resolved her sexual repression over time and with understanding.
 Edward was always too quick to anger — as in his avenging the insult to his Jewish friend. Indeed the violent rage that worried Florence may have been a subconscious element in her attraction: it made him something like her short-fused father. A boat scene keeps the subtle possibility of his sexual abuse of her as a child, the tennis scene the father’s rage over her perceived breach of his privacy. 
Edward chillingly raises a rock when he attacks Florence for not keeping her sexual oath. He throws it into the sea, but not until he has admitted the possibility of his violence against her. The careful graduation of the pebble sizes along the beach — possibly the novel’s central metaphor — parallels the film’s constant nuancing of emotions and their tacit expression. Sailors determine their location from the size of the stones. We navigate our lives according to the proportion we allow our emotions.    
The film’s ending steps outside Edward’s perspective to round out Florence’s future. She married her quintet’s cellist, who had long desired her and himself accused her of hiding her forcefulness under an apparent shyness. He overcame her rejection, married her and developed the sexual relationship signified by their consequent children. 
This Edward first learns when her daughter Chloe buys a Chuck Berry record for Florence’s birthday. Her name and “bouncy and merry” description prove her lineage. Edward doesn’t follow Chloe very far, opting again to withdraw from Florence. But he goes to see her perform at her quintet’s final performance. While Edward retreated to his own musical taste, Florence retained her attachment to the music he introduced her to, even as she advanced her classical career. 
Their career successes similarly contrast. While her college musical group succeeded for  50 years (including the young violinist Florence imposed), Edward abandoned his passion for History and ended up managing a range of vinyl record shops (a pop culture version of history/anthropology). He remarried but had no children and remained broken by his rejection of Florence. They both may have started with Firsts at school, but in overcoming their respective emotional blocks Florence exceeded Edward. 
      Usually an ending imposed in a screen adaptation simplifies or debases the original. The common motive is to provide the happier ending that the mass cinema audience is assumed to demand, more than the solitary reader. McEwan’s addition here serves that purpose in heightening the emotional impact. But it remains wholly congruent with the intentions and effects of his own source. It deepens rather than softening the oiginal. 

Friday, June 29, 2018

The Cakemaker

The film opens and closes on images of Thomas’s poignant mix of solitude and passion. In the first he’s kneading his dough — that’s the activity in which he finds both his self-realization and his antidote to loneliness. At the end he rides his bike away from his Berlin bakery job. He’s going home — as usual, he thinks — alone, but still warmed by the memory of his beloved Oren and Oren's widow Anat. 
But he’s not alone. Anat has tracked him down. She glows with anticipation of their reconnecting. The last image — the clouded skies — signify their challenging but promising future. The film stops before we know if and how they will recover their love. We may guess as we prefer. Or believe. 
Thomas doesn’t lock the front door when he leaves that cafe then. Maybe it locks itself upon closing. Or his leaving it unlocked may signify his openness to Anat’s return to his love.  
       This film’s metaphors work that naturally, like Anat’s radiance at eating Thomas’s cakes and bread — that’s love at first bite. So too the sensuality of Thomas’s baking, the comforting softness in his colour, fleshiness and overall nature. Thomas is doughy himself, and he kneads to be needed. He's malleable to the touch, nourishing. Here love is not romance but an openness to emotions and to life. 
This film abounds with scenes of such quiet suggestions, revelations, nuances in relationship. In the first scene the two men are already familiar with each other — Thomas remembers what pastry Oren doesn’t like. 
Arriving in Jerusalem, Thomas’s isolation is caught in one shot where he’s shrunk to the lower right of the screen, passed by two gesticulating orthodox Jews. The framing and extras define him as alien. In the shower room at Oren’s club Thomas looks at a handsome Jew, then down at his — we infer — uncut alternative.
After stealing a smoke outside after her shabbes dinner, we see Anat boxed in the window frame luxuriating in the verboten last crumbs of his Black Forest Cake. She licks her plate. That frame evokes the religious restriction Moti imposes that she must transcend to find fulfilment with Thomas — as, too, her later discovery that her present lover was her husband’s first. 
  Wordlessly Thomas warms Anat’s runaway son, then involves him in icing the cookies. As with Anat, Thomas slips into an easy bond with the boy, despite his uncle Moti’s impediments. 
In scene after scene the import is in a glance, a gesture, hardly ever verbalized. Thomas (and we) never learn how Oren’s mother twigged to his affair with her son. We just see her immediate warmth towards him, her generosity, and her tacit knowing. 
That understanding lies beyond Anat’s brother Moti, whose initial disdain for “the German” takes cover under the formal strictures of the kosher. Moti makes an effort to accept Thomas — as in his shabbes invitation. 
In contrast, Oren’s mother and son are instinctively drawn to Thomas — as is Anat. In their first sexual engagement Anat takes the initiative. Thomas’s intention has only been to help her. The passion is unexpected.
Perhaps the key to the film’s conception of love lies in the scenes where Thomas asks Oren to describe his most recent love-making with Anat. Initially we might read the scenes as simply erotic. But the context gives them rather more depth and characterization. There is no jealousy, no bitterness. 
Rather Thomas’s embrace of Oren is so complete that it can include the other objects of Oren’s love, his wife and his son. When Thomas makes love to Anat later it is with the memory, gestures and emotion he recalls from Oren. 
Here is a film where love might conquer all. Hence all the divisions that are set up against Thomas — German vs Jew, Berlin vs Jerusalem, Hebrew vs. German/English, bereaved Insider family vs embarrassing Outsider rival, gentile vs Jew, wife vs lover, heterosexual vs homosexual love, etc. 
Thomas’s and Anat’s love for Oren make their falling in love with each other seem entirely credible — however unconventional. How many lovers do have any such strong bond in common? Oren’s mother loved him enough to accept his lover Thomas; so Anat apparently grows to, too. 
      But that acceptance too takes faith. Maybe that’s why Thomas’s cafe is called Credence.  You have to believe.

P.S. A second viewing discovers other possibilities. First, a minor one. At the end Thomas doesn't just leave the cafe door unlocked; he leaves the sidewalk table and chairs out too. He's not locking up, just leaving early, the cafe presumably in the hands of whoever managed it during his sojourn in Jerusalem. More importantly, in Oren's locker Thomas discovers a couple of condoms among the towels. This redefines Oren as someone who has been playing around. Not for him the fidelity and focus Thomas displays when he doesn't respond to the stud in the locker room or the soldier who invitingly heads into the trees. This explains why Oren's last words to Thomas were his assurance that he would never tell Anat of their affair. Yet Anat reveals Oren had just moved out, planning to move to Berlin. Oren has betrayed both his wife and this lover. The capacity for and power of love is rooted in the lover not the beloved.

Monday, June 25, 2018

The City in Cinema (reprint)

City in cinema: impressions
Queen's Quarterly. 107.2 (Summer 2000): p272-85.
When the lights dim and the screen flickers, we see not just a story, but a vision of the urban world as conjured behind the eyes of a Hitchcock or a Scorsese. The way our eyes and ears take in everything from the hue of the city sky to the "tone" of its concrete has been carefully imagined and rendered by a team of hundreds of creative minds, each one an expert in some facet of the grand illusion -- the drift of evening fog, the sound of shoe leather on pavement, the ambience of an empty street. For over a hundred years the cinema has both reflected our vision of the metropolis and helped to shape that vision -- an inevitable process in a century when so much centred on the worlds of city and celluloid.
IN the beginning was the ward. The mental ward. Robert Wiene's The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1919) was far from the first movie, but it established a truth that cinema has tended to hide ever since -- that the setting, like every other component of a film, primarily serves the function of metaphor. It evokes more than it is. Wiene used grotesque painted backdrops to represent the city streets. These expressionist streets, with their jagged edges, violation of perspective, and ominous shadows, express the madness and chaos of the agonized mind. That is to say, the setting did not document a real physical space but expressed a mental state, an attitude, a theme. Although the more realistic cinema has eschewed the extremity of this eccentric film, cinema continues to use the city backdrop as a figure of speech. To hijack Minor White's observation on photography: in cinema the city is not just what's there but what else is there.
Though Wiene's superlative expressionism is rare in the history of film, it has not disappeared. Expressionism lives. When Alfred Hitchcock opens The Lady Vanishes (1938) with an obviously "false" set-up of a toy car wending its way across a Tyrolean tabletop, it's a rhetorical device, not a sign of laziness or economisering. It's one way to say "Once upon a time ..." before unwinding a fanciful tale of grandmotherly espionage and burgeoning love. Similarly, the blatant back projection and the obviously painted slum backdrop in Marnie (1964) are appropriate metaphors for the crippling disjunction between the heroine's present awareness and her suppressed past. More currently, in Ang Lee's The Ice Storm (1997) and Sam Mendes' American Beauty (1999), the houses, streets, storms, and beflowered cheerleader reveal not just where the plots happen but what they mean.
CITIES have often inspired lyrical tributes. Walter Ruttman's Berlin: Symphony of a Great City (1927), a montage of images of that metropolis from dawn to dusk, finds both metaphor and the poeticized mundane in the minutiae of daily life. Observations of an excursion to the beach provide more satiric insights in Menschen am Sonntag (1929), directed by Robert Sidomak and Edgar Ulmer, and co-authored by Fred Zinnemann and Billy Wilder (inchoate masters all). Woody Allen opens Manhattan (1979) with an equivalent serenade to that city's splendours, his editing choreographed to Gershwin. Allen's city abounds with scenes and places of cultural richness and beauty, each one a refuge from storms and barbarism. This film was originally received as a social comedy of rigorous morality, but Allen's notoriety since has inflected it into the pretentious rationalization of a middle-aged man "dating a girl who does homework" (Mariel Hemingway). In this city of sophisticated corruption, the hero's moral high ground becomes the artist's evasion.
Allen's closing shot in Manhattan -- his hero in tragic close-up when apparently he has lost his beloved teenybopper -- specifically evokes Chaplin's City Lights (1931). There Chaplin's Tramp-with-No-Name falls in love with a blind, penurious flower-seller (Virginia Cherrill) and with great sacrifice funds the operation that restores her sight. In Chaplin's last shot the tramp is unreservedly joyful that his beloved can see -- even though her sight dispels forever her illusion that her benefactor is a handsome, wealthy man. After the tramp's sacrifice, what compounds his heroism is his total selflessness. His unmitigated joy reveals that he has harboured no expectation of winning her, so he has no hopes that will be dashed by her disenchanted vision of him. While her dream of a wealthy lover is ruined, Charlie's selfless dream is fulfilled.
This shot exemplifies Chaplin's dictum that tragedy is close-up, comedy long shot. That is, comedy views the human against his social landscape, in his material world, upon the surfaces where pratfalls happen. In contrast, tragedy explores the human in isolation with his fate, abstracted from his quotidian being (i.e., the close-up). The close-up at the end of City Lights is tragic because it expresses the selfless joy of a hero who is doomed to failure, loss, rejection, solitude. In this case, his loss is due to his virtue, his generosity. But this tragic shot concludes a film that is very much bound up with the particulars of life in the city, the comic vision.
For Chaplin the city usually emblematizes the society from which his poor tramp is excluded. His happy ending usually shows him walking away up a country road, typically alone, with his over-reaching shoes, ill-fitting posh suit and cocky bowler, and armed with his thin, bending cane -- the solitary figure indomitable. It's not just that -- as the proverb should have it -- "It's better to have loved and lost," Period, but that Chaplin places his faith in the figure whose self-sufficiency and pluck inure him to the rejections and defeats he inevitably experiences in the city.
In this film Chaplin's basic trope is that people who see by the "city lights" are blind to human worth. The suicidal, wealthy drunk can only recognize Charlie's worth when he's blind drunk. Sober, he doesn't recognize him. The flower-seller appreciates Charlie's worth only so long as she's blind to his social/economic station. When she finally sees him, she is first prompted to condescending amusement, as she witnesses his humiliation. She recognizes him only when she touches him to give him a coin. That is, he is properly identified by his touch and by generosity, not by his shabby, humiliated appearance. The theme of deceptive appearances coheres most of the visual gags in the film, such as a paper streamer mistaken for spaghetti, a bald head for aspic, and the woman's dance invitation he intercepts. Charlie mistakes a modern dance number in the nightclub to be a fight, then turns a prizefight into a dance when he tries to win the money for the girl's eye operation.
In the opening scene, the tramp is discovered sleeping in the lap of a public monument to "Peace and prosperity." The shabby figure in the lap of stone-cold luxury gives the lie to the city's complacent assumptions. As he struggles to extricate himself from the embarrassing situation, he is physically unable to stay on the level with the society's anthem. The gag is a metaphor for the cross-purposes of the tramp and the society. With the statue's help he thumbs his nose at the indignant, nonsensical society. The whole film satirizes the unfeeling veneer of the modern city, its illusions of progress and prosperity despite the plight of its poor and helpless. (Pray Adam Sandier doesn't think to do a contemporary remake!) It also traces the tramp's growth through love from the hypocritical manners of the urbane (e.g., his initial scolding of the newspaper boys, his covert appraisal of the nude sculpture) into a person of genuine and generous feeling.
Unlike Chaplin's suggestion of an Everycity for his Everyman, Hitchcock had a gift for "casting" cities. The titular unease of Vertigo (1958), with its hero's repeated falls from grace, in love as in life, cries out for the rollercoaster streets of San Francisco and the romantic/religious mysteries of its Spanish past. The themes of intrusive voyeurism and its corollary, frigid alienation, in Rear Window (1954) are uniquely served by the tenements of New York, where a wall of windows reveals a cross-section of private lives dubiously exposed in their varying stages of disintegration, like a wall of TV dramas.
In I Confess (1953) Hitchcock used Quebec City for his Manichean investigation of the vulnerability of virtue. A priest (Montgomery Clift) is charged with a blackmailer's murder but is bound to secrecy by the killer's having confessed to him, instead of the police. With few exceptions, the postlapsarian citizenry are malevolent, cruel, judgmental. The Quebec City setting lends a weighty religiosity to the drama, with its steep streets, mortally tempting gardens and gazebos, all those compelling "direction" (i.e., one-way) traffic signs, and the towering cathedra and Stations of the Cross. This city is shown to embody Catholicism -- or at least to express the rich complexity and guilt of a committed Catholic mind. In his signature appearance Hitchcock is the first character we see. He walks in dark silhouette across the high horizon, against the direction of the opening traffic signs that point us to the window of the murder scene. He moves against the mortal grain, aloof from the rules and tensions of ordinary mankind. This initiating spirit is the maker/Maker of the film, the human surrogate of The Creator (or "The Enforcer," to quote the Bogart poster the priest passes later). Like the killer, by walking away from the crime this god figure forces others to face up to it.
Of course, Hitchcock does not consider crime to be exclusively a city phenomenon. It's human nature. So he delights in discovering murderous propensities in that site of traditional American innocence, the small town. In Shadow of a Doubt (1943) an urbane merry widow killer (Joseph Cotten) comes to a small town, but the middle-aged men there already debate expeditious methods of gruesome murder. The sinister hardware store in Psycho (1960) and the demonic visionary in the coffee shop in The Birds (1963) also attach the terrors of life to small-town Americana. The Trouble with Harry (1955) provides the apotheosis of this theme. In gorgeous, autumnal Vermont, dead Harry is continually resurrected and reburied by the citizens who individually assume themselves guilty of having killed him. But hope, love, and the earnest and fertile imagination take root and blossom in such essential awareness. If murder and guilt happen anywhere there are human beings, some of Hitchcock's crimes seem characteristic of the crowded and busy city: the misidentification in The Wrong Man (1956), the aloof inhumanity of the penthouse killers in Rope (1948), and the general amoral smugness from which his heroes are shaken in Strangers on a Train (1951) and all his James Stewart and Cary Grant films.
As the Hitchcock canon suggests, the most popular genres of American film explore the paradoxes and ambivalence of the city. And why not? Arguably the single most important phenomenon in the history of the United States has been the development of its cities, the metamorphosis from wild frontier to urban jungle.
That change is also reflected in the culture's most mythic sports. The semiotics of baseball preserve the culture's pastoral past. The infield is the uniform course that, if the pitch is properly dealt with, invites one to run through safe bases and score by returning home. The outfield -- whose dimensions may vary from stadium to stadium -- is the unmeasured wilds beyond this skeleton of community, the reminder of the pre-suburban outland. In contrast, football is a game of steady grabbing of land, one ten-yard block at a time, against equally heroic resistance. Here the primary focus is on the immediate yard of embattled ground, not the ball. The culture's switch from baseball to football as the all-American game mirrors the nation's growth from a country of small towns to one dominated by the great city. "The boys of summer" remain icons of nostalgia, a remembrance of things past, an eternal adolescence manifest in the elderly managers still dressing in the boys' uniforms. But it's the behemoths of the fall -- whose coaches wear business suits -- that speak for the contemporary psyche in America. Baseball sustains the myth of small-town America, football the industry, violence, and pressure of the modern city. Of course, hockey is Canada's European play of finessing space for a goal, like soccer -- but on ice.
But I digress. Back to the popular genres -- the musical, crime film, and Western -- and their take on the city.
THE musical propagates the myth that the city is the paradise of opportunity, the community of generous spirits, the testing ground and validation of individualism (albeit harnessed to the harmonies of the troupe). Why, every town in Kansas must have a Mickey and a Judy ready to "put on a show" of Ziegfieldian pizzazz. Typically, the young, beautiful, talented heroes emerge from the farms and towns to become stars in the city. The City is New York -- which is so alluring it's a threat to the old-fashioned 1903 family of Vincent Minnelli's Meet Me in St Louis (1944). New York is where everyone -- even blustery fathers like Leon Ames -- must move to prove their advancement.
If one is to believe the Hollywood musical, such as Richard Quine's My Sister Eileen (1955), the stranger to New York has only to erupt into song and/or dance in the street and she is immediately supported by a horde of loving, dependable strangers (what we might call "Blanche Dubois Syndrome"). In Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins' West Side Story (1961) this aestheticizing of reality extends to turning gang warfare into jazz ballet -- as rape is in Stanley Donen's Seven Brides for Seven Brothers (1954), but that's country folk.
New York is the high life, where champagne flows, everyone is elegant, and wealth, love, and fame await those who qualify -- not by birth (as in old, obsolete Europe) but by that most egalitarian qualification of the elect -- talent. This is the theme of The Purple Rose of Cairo (1985), where a pathetic housewife (Mia Farrow) wins the heart of a fictitious character -- and even, briefly, that of the actor who portrays him (Jeff Daniels both) -- by her virtue, sincerity, and her knack with a ukulele. Hollywood's fantasies of the glamorous city sustain the realistically deprived.
These same values propel the crime film. Nonentities grow into "stars" by exercising their individualism, transcending societal norms, scampering up the ladder of the city's nightlife, one rat-a-tat success at a time. In both genres the city represents opportunity, rivalry, the testing ground for individualist ambitions in tension with codes of restraining community. Both genres celebrate individuals' triumph of will, eccentric characters, and the happy blend of ambition and talent. Before the hoofer becomes a star and the gunsel transforms into head honcho, they have to pay their dues to the team, biding their time, whether holding up the chorus line or stepping to the boss's measure. Both genres show heroes espousing style and dash, whether the top hat and tails of the musical or the shiny new suit that always marks the start of a gangster's rise.
In both genres the city streets are paved with guilt -- and sometimes gold. Where the musical thrives on colour -- the opulence of wealth and glamour, even in the pre-Technicolor shimmering silvers of black and white Astaire-cases to paradise -- the crime film lives in and exposes the shadows. It's the post-psychoanalytic cinema, exposing the dark alleys behind the glamorous nightclubs. A Star is Born could be the title of any of those films named after a legend: Capone, Bugsy (Siegel or Malone), The Godfathers, Lepke, Machine Gun Kelly, Scarface, Lucky Luciano. With the exception of Bonny and Clyde all the major gangster epics are big city figures, because the challenge and rewards of the teeming urban society signify crime. A Legs Diamond could rise and fall in either genre.
But of all the genres, it is the Western that is primarily about the city. Paradoxically, true, for what we mainly see is the pre-city, the desert and at most the small towns from which the cities sprang. This is a classic case of the presence of absence. The Western chronicles the culture's transition from the wild to the settled, from the loner's range to community. As the Western details the beginnings of the city, it provides a nostalgic recollection of the pre-urban golden age, its lost Eden, its innocent infancy. That's why so many Westerns are titled after cities/states (Carson City, Santa Fe Trail, Dodge City, Virginia City, 3:10 to Yuma, Vera Cruz, San Francisco, Dallas, In Old Arizona, Tulsa, Dakota, In Old Oklahoma, Cheyenne, and of course the ever-popular Saskatchewan) or emblems of the country's settlement (Union Pacific, Western Union, Winchester 73, The Tin Star, The Covered Wagon, The Iron Horse, The Iron Mistress -- which incidentally refers to Jim Bowie's knife, not a rusty lover) or people from iconic places (The Man from Utah, The Man from Laramie, The Virginian, The Oklahoma Kid).
Some of the Western's most important scenes catch the turning point of frontier into civilization. In John Ford's My Darling Clementine (1946) the nomadic gunman Wyatt Earp (Henry Fonda) evolves into the model sheriff when he rides into the incipient town, gets a haircut and shave at the barbershop, puts on his Sunday suit and does a stiff, determined dance with the civilized Clementine (Cathy Downs) on the clean floorboards of the unfinished church -- before dispatching the villainous Clantons at the OK Corral. The city-culture woman here represents an advance upon the earthier Chihuahua (Linda Darnell) as Grace Kelly does to Katy Jurado in Fred Zinnemann's High Noon (1952). But the latter patrician pacifist learns from the rougher heroine the need to shoot a man in the back to save her husband.
The structure of Ford's The Man who Shot Liberty Valance (1962) can be called analytic nostalgia, specifically as it harkens back to the origins of the legalized community. Senator Ransom Stoddard (James Stewart) and his wife (Vera Miles) return to the old town for the funeral of the unknown Tom Doniphon (John Wayne). As a young lawyer Stoddard built his political reputation on the story that he killed the notorious outlaw, Liberty Valance (Lee Marvin). Now Stoddard reveals that he never in fact performed the heroic feat. The real hero was Doniphon, who from the shadows shot Valance before the villain could kill the wounded lawyer. This film captures the ambivalence of the modern order. For the law to take its hold, there has to be a civilized outlaw, in the shadows, to support it. The pen may be mightier than the sword, but it won't survive without a gun to protect it. When he spurns the credit for ridding the community of the lawless villain, Doniphon loses his girl (Miles), throws away his future, and watches his maladroit friend rise to fame -- and relative fatuity. As the villain's name subtly reminds us, liberty is ambivalent. At the same time, the corruption and the orchestrated chaos of the early political convention, which launches Stoddard's career, reminds us of the negative valence that persists in the world of the city.
Sam Peckinpah's Ride the High Country (1961) brilliantly calibrates that transition. Here the Western town already has sidewalks and a policeman (not a sheriff) to keep the pedestrians on them. Taking advantage of the community's cultural openness, someone has imported a camel to race against the horses of the locals -- an early form of urban con. As antiquated lawmen come upon hard times, the iconic Randolph Scott and Joel McCrea (Scott assuming McCrea's persona of Buffalo Bill) dig deep to reaffirm their unfashionable ethic and self-respect. Their elemental dignity transcends the savage brothers' marriage in a brothel and the inveigled bride's vicious Bible-thumping father. (The moral theme of this fable fades in the film's British release rifle, Guns in the Afternoon.)
In the Western film, the city is as ambivalent as progress -- because it represents progress. While the city brings new community it also brings the compromise of traditional values. In John Ford's seminal Stagecoach (1939), the eponymous ship of fools crosses the savage wilds between -- get this -- Apache Wells and Lordsburg. Not all the savages are those pesky redskins dispatched to bite the Monument Valley dust. The town is characterized by a larcenous banker and a vigilante committee of high sassiety women. Virtue resides in the outcasts, the drunken doctor, the noble gambler rejected by his Old South family, the golden-hearted whore, and the ex-con, the Ringo Kid (John Wayne). By sending Ringo and the ex-whore-elect (Claire Trevor) off to Ringo's homestead, the sheriff wants to "save them from the blessings of civilization." In the pastoralism of the Western the city is a mixed blessing indeed.
Clint Eastwood's High Plains Drifter (1972) is a surrealistic exorcism of the progressivist view of the Western town. Eastwood plays a ghostlike figure who emerges from a mist, disappears in another, and in between scourges the oceanside town of Lago. He renames it Hell and has it painted entirely red, a rather candid form of urban renewal. The good citizens of Lago dread the return of a trio of killers fresh out of prison. They give the spectral hero a community carte blanche -- whatever it takes to protect them. But the hero is none other than the shade of their former sheriff, whom none of the townfolk aided as he was bullwhipped to death by the very same villains. When this hero goes to the barber shop, instead of getting a simple clip and shave he kills three men and rapes the town tease. No Henry Fonda hero he. As the spineless new marshal explains, "the price of progress" is doing what has to be done for the good of the community, which includes seeing the previous sheriff killed so he won't reveal that the town's big mine is actually on government land. With its situational parallels and town-gunman tensions, this film plays Experience to the Innocence of High Noon (incidentally, as Eastwood's Pale Rider did to George Stevens' Shane).
Before Eastwood slipped out of his saddle to play his modern San Francisco detective, Harry Callahan, he rehearsed his urbanization with Coogan's Bluff (1968, director Don Siegel). This time the Westerner's savvy, skills, and intuition exceed the petty restraints and restrictions of the urbanites. Eastwood plays an Arizona deputy who has to track down an escaped killer through the exotic canyons of modern New York City, where the licentious savages are the hippies.
Films that depict a cowboy figure out of place in the modern world remind us of the Western's relationship to the city. In John Schlesinger's Midnight Cowboy(1969)Joe Buck (Jon Voigt) is an ambitious stud who comes up from the chorus line in Texas intending to become a star gigolo in Manhattan. Instead he discovers grace and camaraderie with the guttersnipe "Ratzo" Rizzo (Dustin Hoffman), who dies as he nears his illusionary Nirvana: Florida. Far superior (and less known) is David Miller's Lonely are the Brave (1962), where Kirk Douglas plays an idealistic ex-con cowboy in search of frontier freedom. But he's pursued by the modern technocrat sheriff (Walter Matthau) and killed with his fine black steed on the freeway by a truck full of toilets (driven by Carroll O'Conner before he was Archie Bunker). The city kills the cowboy, but in urbanized America the cowboy spirit survives.
In the Canadian equivalent, Peter Pearson's classic Paperback Hero (1972), Keir Dullea plays a rural Saskatchewan hockey star who has bought into the American Western myth so completely that he's unaware he has become a parody. His inability to discriminate between himself and his delusion proves fatal. Perhaps his illusions of martyrdom save him from growing old and self-aware. Here the town has no real place for the delusions of a self-styled cowboy. Of course, the central distinction of this film is the additional theme of the Canadian killing himself with an American posture -- a point slightly mitigated by importing an American b-level "star" to play the Canadian playing at being the American hero. The Canadian serious film industry was young then.
SO which is the ream city -- the land of shimmering opportunity or the strangling jungle of shadows and corruption? My point is that there is no real city in the movies. For some Out-of-Towners (Arthur Hiller, 1970; Sam Weisman, 1999) it proves to be The Band Wagon (Vincent Minnelli, 1953), for others The Rat Race (Robert Mulligan, 1960). There are instead thousands of fantasies about the naked city. You pay your money and you see someone else's choice of fantasy. The city of film is a figure of speech, a poetic setting. It's what the artist chooses to make of it. Like life.
Source Citation   (MLA 8th Edition)
Yacowar, Maurice. "City in cinema: impressions." Queen's Quarterly, vol. 107, no. 2, 2000, pp. 272-85. Academic OneFile, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A30033235/AONE?u=ucalgary&sid=AONE&xid=b77d592c. Accessed 25 June 2018.